No IAF plane used to repatriate Indian immigrants since 2020: Govt
The Centre has recently informed the Rajya Sabha that since 2020, the Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) has not hired any Indian Air Force (IAF) aircraft, chartered aircraft, or commercial aircraft for repatriating Indian immigrants. This revelation has sparked curiosity among many, especially those who are aware of similar practices being followed in other countries, including the United States.
In a written response to a question raised by Rajya Sabha member Pabitra Margherita, the Centre clarified that Indian immigrants facing deportation were assisted in returning home on a means-tested basis through the purchase of tickets on commercial flights. This means that the government did not use any special arrangement or aircraft for repatriating Indian immigrants, instead opting for regular commercial flights.
This clarification from the Centre has raised questions about the government’s approach towards repatriating Indian immigrants who are facing deportation. While the government’s decision to use commercial flights for repatriation may seem like a cost-effective and practical solution, it also raises concerns about the welfare and safety of these individuals.
In contrast, the United States has been using military planes for deportations since 2025. The US Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has been utilizing military aircraft to transport deported individuals back to their home countries. This approach has been criticized by human rights activists, who argue that it is a costly and inhumane practice.
The use of military planes for deportations has also been linked to human rights abuses, with reports of mistreatment and abuse of deportees during the transportation process. In addition, the use of military aircraft for deportations has been criticized for being a symbol of the US’s harsh immigration policies.
In comparison, India’s approach to repatriation seems more humane and practical. By using commercial flights, the government is able to provide a safer and more comfortable travel experience for Indian immigrants who are facing deportation. Additionally, the use of commercial flights is likely to be more cost-effective than using military planes or chartered aircraft.
However, the government’s decision to use commercial flights for repatriation also raises concerns about the welfare and safety of these individuals. Deportees often face difficulties and challenges during their journey back to their home countries, including language barriers, cultural shock, and social isolation. The government’s decision to use commercial flights may not provide adequate support and assistance to these individuals, who may be vulnerable and in need of special care.
In conclusion, the Centre’s decision to use commercial flights for repatriating Indian immigrants since 2020 is a practical and cost-effective solution, but it also raises concerns about the welfare and safety of these individuals. While India’s approach may be more humane than the US’s use of military planes for deportations, it is still important to ensure that deportees receive adequate support and assistance during their journey back to their home countries.
